The Strays – Emily Bitto

I plucked Emily Bitto’s debut The Strays out of my classroom library, but after having read it, I don’t think I will put it back. It’s not because there is anything contentious to be found between the book’s covers; I just doubt that any of my students would pick it up, and if they did, I don’t think they would actually read the whole thing.

The Strays is about the narrator Lily’s friendship with Eva Trentham, middle daughter of Helena and Evan Trentham. The story of Lily’s association with this family comes racing back to her when she receives a letter from Eva, from whom she has been long estranged, inviting her to a retrospective of Evan’s work. (He is a well known avant garde painter.)

The story spins from the 1960s back to the 1930s when Lily meets Eva in the third grade. The girls form a fast and firm friendship, and soon Lily is spending more time at the Trentham enclave than she is at home with her own parents.

The Trentham’s house had been in Helena’s family for three generations. Its charm was of the ramshackle kind, tacked together over years and across architectural periods so that it resembled those European churches with one Gothic wing and one Renaissance. […] At the Trenthams’ we were left gloriously alone to ride the rooftops or circumnavigate the garden as we desired.

Eva’s parents are not like Lily’s. The girls, including Eva’s older sister, Bea, and younger sister, Heloise, are really mostly left to their own devices. Lily is fascinated with the family dynamics, and soon finds herself just one of the daughters — if only just marginally. I mean, what’s one more kid kicking around the place?

We know from the book’s opening that Eva and Lily are estranged all these years later, although Lily has maintained a relationship with Bea. The invitation acts as a catalyst for Lily’s memories, but also as a plot device for the reader. What happened to this unbreakable bond?

Evan Trentham is something of a celebrity in the art world and soon other young artists are living at the house. In her author’s note, Bitto says that the novel is “inspired by stories of the Melbourne art world in the 1930s and ’40s, and contains references to certain historical events and people.” I know nothing about art or the scene, so that stuff went over my head. Not sure it really matters.

I think The Strays is a well-written book, but I also found that not too much really happens and that the reason for the estrangement isn’t altogether worth it when you finally land there. Still, it was an interesting read, though probably not for teenagers who will be looking for way more to happen in way less time.

Leave a Reply